Friday, September 30, 2011

Material World



In our Global Citizenship Study we are looking at many books by Peter Menzel, such as Hungry Planet, and today, Material World.  In this book, instead of people from different countries putting their food out, they put their family possessions out in front of their homes.  We observed that some people had a lot of possessions and some people didn’t have much at all.  We recorded on a sheet of paper what we noticed about each country and what we wondered.  

Here are some of the things we noticed:

  • The TV seemed very important in the picture of Mexico
  • In South Africa they had two beds for seven people
  • In Cuba the houses are in bad shape
  • In Mali they have lots of pots
  • In Thailand they had mosquito nets over their beds
  • In Kuwait there are lots of couches and cars
  • In Japan they had 32 pairs of shoes for four people
  • In South Africa they wrote that their most valued possession was their family
  • In Mongolia they only have one room to sleep and eat in
  • In USA they had a lot of stuff for pleasure and in other countries they had only stuff they needed
  • In Iceland it seemed like musical instruments were important (only place that had them)
  • In Mexico one of the kids was holding either a fake or real pistol
Here are some things we wondered:
  • In Mongolia how do they walk around at night without any electricity?
  • Why do the people in Bhutan have so many children?
  • Where do the people in Mali sleep (what do they sleep on?)
  • In Mongolia I wonder what their houses are made of, they look like giant pick up sticks?
  • What happens when it rains in Mongolia?
  • In Mongolia their most prized possession was a TV, but they live in a tent.  How do they get their power?
  • How did they make their house?
  • In Samoa what are their animals used for?
  • In Cuba what do people sleep on?
  • In Mali what are all the wooden tools for?
  • In Mongolia do they ever feel cramped?  They have a lot furniture, but not a lot of space.
Big Questions:
  • Do most people want more stuff, or are they fine with what they have?
  • I wonder why a lot of the families are religious?
  • I wonder what percentage of the people live in poverty?
  • Why does America and Japan have so much stuff compared to other countries?
  • I wonder how people in different countries share their beds when they don’t have enough for each person?
  • How are the countries related in terms of material?
  • Why are some countries more wealthy than others?
  • What country has the least amount of possessions?
  • How much does each countries possessions cost them?

5 comments:

  1. I noticed the family from Mali has there bike as there most valuable possession is their bike because to get to the market their father would need to walk for four hours and on a bike ride for two.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I noticed that to. I think you are right

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Kyle,
    I noticed that in some countries physical handicaps are prevalent. I wonder, is it a normal part of life, especially in war stricken countries? My big question is, in those countries, is the focus so much on survival, that they are grateful for every minute they have?
    Kind regards,
    Tracy Watanabe

    ReplyDelete
  4. I really like that question "Do most people want more stuff, or are they fine with what they have?" It would be interesting if you could ask that question of people all around the world and see what they say. I'll bet some people actually need more stuff than they have, and some might have just the right amount. I know many of us have too much stuff. I would be happy with less stuff, and more time to enjoy what I do have.

    Thanks for sharing this blog with me. I will check it regularly now to see what 5th graders are doing!

    Alice Moore

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think that most family's would want more because there are a lot of family's that aren't very fortunate.

    ReplyDelete